Özet:

There are three different reports about the heritage (guide/s) that the Prophet left to Ummah in sources of hadith and history: 1. The Book of God 2. The Book of Allah and Ahl al-Bayt. The book of Allah and the Sunna of the Prophet In this article, the report that expresses "The book and Sunna left as heritage" which is one of the important supports for determining the hierarchy of evidence for Ahl al-Sunna is taken as the subject of study from the earliest sources chronologically and analyzed both from al-isnad and textual point of view. The conclusion reached in this article by analyzing the isnads is that these reports expressing are weak according to classical hadith methodology. Because the content of the hadith includes the two bases of religion they cannot be counted among the subjects at which weak hadiths are allowed to be used as wisdom of acts, al-maghazi etc. When approached the subject from the textual point of view, The Prophet leaving three different things and despite it being recited in "The Final Sermon" that ten thousands of ashab listened to it being with three different contents looks problematic.

Anahtar Kelimeler: